Thursday, September 19, 2019

7. Are Problems Perceived by Many?


1. Teacher Morale in Public Education

2. There is a national teacher shortage that is increasing yearly.  With fewer and fewer people pursuing a degree in education, we are going to have a limited ability to staff public school, and it will almost be impossible to find highly effective teachers.

The Who: Public Schools in America
The What: Have a limited opportunity to hire and retain staff at public schools
The Why: Teacher morale

3. I conducted interviews with the CCEA president, elementary school teachers, high school teachers, staff from the school, and school resource deputies.

4. How can the problem be expanded?

Who: Before, I thought that it was really the teachers that were struggling with morale in schools.  After the interviews, all of the elements of the schools are struggling with these issues.  The staff acting as Title 1 support, classroom aides, and administrative assistants are all feeling this pressure that has worked its way from the top as well.  Much of it has to do with a changing dynamic of students, but I will discuss several other factors later.  Not to mention, the administration of the school has the pressure of the school board and the superintendent from state and federal mandates.  This will ultimately roll down hill and will affect the abilities of those in the classroom.  Because these mandates are increasing in nature, I would like to believe that a majority of people in the field are feeling the effects and the data shows how many people are leaving.

What: When asked about the extent of the problem, several teachers admitted that they no longer suggest that people even go into the field of education because it has become so intolerable.  One of the teachers I spoke with that was struggling with the field after being in it for a long time has since quit with the enrollment of new curriculum.  Fortunately, for them, they are now an entrepreneur and are selling fudge and other desserts.  For other teachers, they feel stuck in these roles because their only retirement is through the state.  If they had a 401k or IRA, they could possibly change fields and still be on track to retire.  The CCEA president has been fighting for increases in wages and looking for ways to improve the implementation of mandates, but it's a difficult process when nobody wants to be involved anymore.

Why: In reality, there are a number of factors that are affecting how teachers/staff/administration perform in school.  I mentioned that morale is an issue.  Beyond that I discovered this morale issue has foundational components contributing to the issue.  Respect from the students has become an increasing factor, lack of mental health concerns for teachers and staff, local, state, and federal mandates, new testing implementation, new curriculum, decrease in the feeling of safety at schools.  The list goes on and on.  The teachers were very open to change and wanted to see formidable solutions to what they were evoking.  They feel lost and hopeless and need help or the field will eventually deteriorate.

5. Some of the things that I heard about the schools were incredible and shocking.  I found out that SRDs are being cursed at and beaten by students.  We see teachers going through traumatic experiences without necessary help.  I truly believe that the issue is much worse than I could have originally expected.  Even as an opportunist, I am at a loss for words with what is going on in our education system.  One solution that I do not think is really important is the money aspect.  As much as I would like to see more money in the education system, we typically spend it on more unnecessary bureaucratic processes.  We need to be more effective with the money in the system, and if we do place more money towards the issue it needs to be used to improve mental health of the teachers and students, create positions that pay decent wages, and develop a greater transparency where teachers/staff feel free to express their thoughts.  

3 comments:

  1. Nicholas,
    This issue really hits home for me as many turn a blind eye to the education crisis. I've watched several of my peers graduate from FSU and UF and they already have become teachers at a middle and high school level. They certainly aren't doing it for the money, so I must agree that the money aspect isn't the most ideal solution. The fact that one of the teachers you spoke with decided to quit due to changing curriculum highlights another issue with the education system. Federal regulations deprive students from an ideal learning environment, and to make matters worse, some companies are profiting immensely due to these regulations.

    ReplyDelete
  2. Nicholas,
    I am very happy that you have chosen this as your issue because I think it's necessary that we as students understand what school looks like from the other side. Even in my own education career, I remember school changing drastically as I moved through K-12. We witnessed some of our teachers be left with the extreme pressure of building test taking machines instead of honest future leaders, this creates a disconnect from both sides. Most people go in to education to not only provide education to young minds but to assist the development of good people. Great job!

    ReplyDelete
  3. Nicholas,

    My families is friends with lots of teachers in Orlando and I actually had a chance to talk to my teacher last year about this before I graduated. The teacher I spoke to, Mary Cumberland, decided to leave our school and to work for a failing school instead. Seminole County has some of the best schools in Florida and for a great morale teacher like her to leave left us in shock. When I asked why she was moving to a worse school she responded its for the kids and not to mention the extra money. She saw the need that these students needed a teacher with morales to help them succeed. Now there are laws that pay teachers more for working in schools that struggle more. As students at a competitive school we know how impactful teachers can be.

    ReplyDelete